The present is the primary, child steps in the direction of cleansing up the Tamil comedy house, which largely speaks to and is centered across the IT crowd
When Amazon Prime Video rolled out the primary version of Comicstaan in 2018, one of many criticisms held towards the present, regardless of offering a platform for homegrown comics to learn from, was how predictable the jokes had been and the way sketchy the sketches had been, when in comparison with the usual set by worldwide exhibits — with regard to content material and format.
If that would occur to Comicstaan, mentored and judged by a distinguished panel of comics who (in)appropriately have change into the face of stand-up in India, a present which could historically be construed liberal if seen from the prism of the South, you possibly can think about what to not count on from Comicstaann ̶S̶e̶m̶m̶a̶ ̶C̶o̶m̶e̶d̶y̶ ̶P̶a̶.
It helps when you’ve got seen the shockingly-banal trailer, for, it units the tone and, in a means, prepares you for what’s about to unfold on the present. However however right here’s the excellent news: the Tamil model of Comicstaan shouldn’t be as dangerous as one would have thought it could be. It nonetheless is shaky, plastic-ky and largely unfunny in components. However allow us to save that for later.
Not like Comicstaan, which had over 10 judges and 10 contestants, the Tamil model has a shorter format (with eight episodes with a run time of 45 minutes every) and has three judges — Karthik Kumar, Praveen Kumar and Rajmohan Arumugam — mentoring a staff of six comics, Syama Harini, Abhishek Kumar, Mayandi Karunanithi, Yogesh Jagannathan and Anamalai Lakshmanan, who’re put to acid check in numerous genres of comedy: sketch, anecdotal, topical, comedy of errors and so forth.
The comics, after their preliminary resistance to cocoon out of their consolation zone, come alive and exhibit their persona — apparently one of many necessities in stand-up — because the present proceeds. However the place Comicstaan Semma Comedy Pa will get attention-grabbing is comedy of errors, a type of improv the place comics are given subjects on the spot. Improv, in a cricket glossary, is like Check cricket which can actually decide whether or not you nonetheless have it. Some escape unscathed, whereas the injury has been finished.
However the harsh reality is: there’s not a single comic who’s extremely humorous. In fact, there’s Abhishek Kumar — identified for his Janaki trainer movies — whose theatrics assist him in attaining a sure type of response. There may be Syama Harini, the one feminine comedian who owns the stage like no one does. There may be additionally Yogesh whose greatest power appears to be making you purchase into his cluelessness.
Maybe the most important asset of Comicstaan Semma Comedy Pa is Karthik Kumar; he’s pretty tutorial, tends to theorise punchlines, and explains why the joke is working or the place the development is faltering. As is Praveen Kumar, a self-proclaimed grasp of puns, insisting on tight units with tighter punchlines. It’s absolute pleasure to observe Karthik break down the basics of theatre; his analogies make you marvel why a few of his acts usually are not as rapturous as he sounds them to be, one thing he himself confesses — “I’m barely in a complicated section proper now and that occurs to all of us.” Rajmohan Arumugam is a misfit right here, though his Mudumalai forest gag is a scream. Mervyn Rozario who has turned host looks like a greater match.
The present, if something, is a ghastly reflection of why the Tamil stand-up comedy scene is essentially pedestrian and doesn’t transcend the English-speaking, whiskey-drinking crowd with whom it’s related to.
Even a number of the premises that the comedians work on, are predominantly written and carried out to the #StraightOutta IT crowd, which occupies the dominant a part of in the present day’s viewers, each inside and out of doors the present — it isn’t to be taken as a critique of the privileged lot. That’s not the purpose I’m attempting to make.
I’m speaking of a comedy that’s ours; that is freed from courses, that’s firmly rooted, not only for the sake of it. Once I say ours, allow us to not limit the broadly-varied spectrum to 3 subjects: Tamil cinema, IPL and girls’s points. Even the jokes written round these are, for the shortage of a greater phrase, vegetarian. Which is why I favored the dry humour that runs in Mayandi Karunanidhi’s units higher; he’s informal, easy and doesn’t appear to care that he’s performing. Maybe, what the South lacks within the comedy house is a Biswa Kalyan Rath, a Zakir Khan and even the latest Akash Gupta.
What we hope to see sooner or later, if there’s a Season Two of Comistaann ̶S̶e̶m̶m̶a̶ ̶C̶o̶m̶e̶d̶y̶ ̶P̶a̶ that’s, is extra variety among the many judges and among the many contestants.
Comicstaan Semma Comedy Pa is streaming on Amazon Prime Video